Primitive Culture 20: Would You Rather? / by Trek fm

Star Trek's Impossible Choices.

Running Time: 1 hour 12 minutes 35 seconds
Download / RSS / Send us a message / Discuss the show / Support Trek.fm

Since the publication of William Styron's novel Sophie's Choice in 1979, the title has entered the cultural lexicon as a term meaning a difficult situation in which a person must choose between two equally deserving alternatives. Two Star Trek episodes-Discovery's "Lethe" and Voyager's "Latent Image," both written by Joe Menosky-borrow the story's horrifying central conceit: a mother forced to choose between her children. In Jeri Taylor's Voyager novel Mosaic, we learn that a similarly unbearable choice early in Kathryn Janeway's Starfleet career almost destroyed her chances at command, plunging her into deep depression.

In this episode of Primitive Culture, hosts Clara Cook and Duncan Barrett consider Star Trek's approach to impossible choices. For the men and women who want to sit in the captain's chair, part of their training involves facing the most terrible dilemmas-sending a friend to his death to save the ship or facing the ultimate no-win scenario: the Kobayashi Maru. But are some choices just too awful for human beings to cope with? And what happens when being forced to choose makes us lose something we can never get back?

Chapters

Intro (00:00:00)
"Lethe" (00:04:43)
"Latent Image" (00:13:00)
Boundaries of Impossibility (00:23:00)
Mosaic (00:31:45)
The Kobayashi Maru (00:36:15)
"Children of Time" and Generational Empathy (00:38:20)
The Needs of the Many (00:50:45)
Twenty-first-century Choices (01:02:00)

Hosts

Clara Cook and Duncan Barrett

Production

Clara Cook (Editor) Duncan Barrett (Producer) C Bryan Jones (Executive Producer) Matthew Rushing (Executive Producer) Ken Tripp (Executive Producer) Norman C. Lao (Associate Producer) Amy Nelson (Associate Producer) Richard Marquez (Production Manager) Brandon-Shea Mutala (Patreon Manager)

More recent episodes of Primitive Culture…
Primitive Culture 126: Progressive Nostalgia?
Primitive Culture 126: Progressive Nostalgia?

Music in Star Trek. We take a look at how Trek’s underscore has developed over more than half a century with musicologists Jessica Getman and Evan Ware.

Primitive Culture 125: Five-Year Mission
Primitive Culture 125: Five-Year Mission

Half a Decade of Primitive Culture. In this special episode, recorded earlier this year, we look back on the podcast and how Star Trek has changed in the time we’ve been podcasting.

Primitive Culture 124: Just Following Orders?
Primitive Culture 124: Just Following Orders?

Cardassian war crimes and The Man in the Glass Booth. We look at the DS9 episode “Duet” alongside The Man in the Glass Booth, as well as the presentation of war crimes in Star Trek more generally.

Primitive Culture 123: Neurodiversity in Infinite Combinations
Primitive Culture 123: Neurodiversity in Infinite Combinations

Autistic representation in Star Trek. We look at Trek’s history of (accidental) representation of neurodiversity, considering characters such as Data, Seven of Nine, Reginald Barclay, and Sylvia Tilly.

Primitive Culture 122: Identical Strangers
Primitive Culture 122: Identical Strangers

Star Trek’s Double Troubles. We look doppelgängers and duplicates from The Original Series through Lower Decks.

Primitive Culture 121: When Is an Allegory Not an Allegory?
Primitive Culture 121: When Is an Allegory Not an Allegory?

Trans Representation in Star Trek. We look at how Star Trek accidentally addressed the topic in TNG and DS9.

Primitive Culture 120: Resurrecting Nightmares
Primitive Culture 120: Resurrecting Nightmares

The Alien franchise and Star Trek: Strange New Worlds. We take a look at “All Those Who Wander” alongside the Alien franchise.

Primitive Culture 119: Cowboy Diplomats
Primitive Culture 119: Cowboy Diplomats

How Star Trek’s leaders reflect our own. We talk about the parallels between Star Trek’s leaders and our own, and ask whether Star Trek has finally managed to marry the military ethos of Starfleet with the business of intergalactic politics.

Primitive Culture 118: Servants to Two Masters
Primitive Culture 118: Servants to Two Masters

Star Trek’s backdoor pilots. We take a look at the original attempt to establish a spinoff series, “Assignment: Earth,” as well as more recent examples including Strange New Worlds and more potential offspring of Discovery.

Primitive Culture 117: What If …
Primitive Culture 117: What If …

What if it wasn’t the Vulcans who made first contact? In honor of First Contact Day, we imagine how things might have played out for humanity had it been the Klingons, Romulans, or others passing by on April 5, 2063.