Commentary: Trek Stars 4: Series Finale Beta Testing / November 29, 2012 by Trek fm

Roddenberry Part 3: Assignment: Earth.

After two seasons on the air, the cancellation of Star Trek seemed to be inevitable. In order to hedge his bets, Gene Roddenberry designed the probable series finale to be a backdoor pilot for a new show entitled Assignment: Earth.

This week, Max and Mike are joined by Trek.fm’s TOS editor Drew Stewart to discuss what “Assignment: Earth” is and what it would have been, how it differs from Trek’s portrayal of Roddenberry’s world view, how it worked as a self-contained pilot and as an episode of Star Trek, and whether or not season one of Assignment: Earth would have been preferable to season three of Star Trek.

Hosts

Mike Shindler and Max Hegel

Chapters

Introduction to Assignment: Earth
“Assignment: Earth” as the Pilot of a New Show
The Concept as a Whole
“Assignment: Earth” as an episode of Star Trek
Background Information

More Recent Episodes Of Commentary: Trek Stars

Commentary: Trek Stars

Commentary: Trek Stars 182: Let's See What's Out There

about 8 years ago

Series Finale. Mike and John reflect the past three and a half years of podcasting.

Commentary: Trek Stars 181: Deep Cuts

about 8 years ago

Lin, Part 8: Recap. Mike and John recap their series on Justin Lin.

Commentary: Trek Stars 180: Faster, More Intense

about 8 years ago

Lin, Part 7: Furious 6. John and Mike are joined by Megan from Educating Geeks to discuss Justin Lin's Furious 6.

Commentary: Trek Stars 179: The Avengers of Fast & Furiousness

about 8 years ago

Lin, Part 6: Fast Five. Mike and John discuss Justin Lin's sixth film, Fast Five.

Commentary: Trek Stars 178: Getting Rid of the Thes

about 8 years ago

Lin, Part 5: Fast & Furious. John and Mike are joined by Zach Moore to discuss Justin Lin's fifth movie, Fast & Furious.

View the full Commentary: Trek Stars episode directory >

Commentary: Trek Stars 3: Proto-Roddenberry / November 22, 2012 by Trek fm

Roddenberry Part 2: The Lieutenant.

Star Trek is not the only show to be created by Gene Roddenberry. Three years prior, Gary Lockwood (aka Gary Mitchell) starred as The Lieutenant in Gene Roddenberry’s debut series about a U.S. Marine Corps officer serving during peace time.

This week, Mike and Max examine an episode which features numerous Trek cast and crew members (including Leonard Nimoy) in an attempt to determine what the series on the whole was like. We discuss what makes The Lieutenant different from other military shows, how those differences reflect Roddenberry’s world view, how the Vietnam War killed the show, what the similarities are between The Lieutenant and Star Trek, and how the failure of The Lieutenant may have shaped Star Trek into the show it would eventually become. We also examine the landscape of television in the early ’60s and debate whether or not “Mitchell” is the best episode of Mystery Science Theater 3000.

Hosts

Mike Shindler and Max Hegel

Chapters

Introduction to The Lieutenant
Star Trek Directors and The Lieutenant
Roddenberry and TV of the Era
Did The Lieutenant Lead to Star Trek?

More Recent Episodes Of Commentary: Trek Stars

Commentary: Trek Stars

Commentary: Trek Stars 182: Let's See What's Out There

about 8 years ago

Series Finale. Mike and John reflect the past three and a half years of podcasting.

Commentary: Trek Stars 181: Deep Cuts

about 8 years ago

Lin, Part 8: Recap. Mike and John recap their series on Justin Lin.

Commentary: Trek Stars 180: Faster, More Intense

about 8 years ago

Lin, Part 7: Furious 6. John and Mike are joined by Megan from Educating Geeks to discuss Justin Lin's Furious 6.

Commentary: Trek Stars 179: The Avengers of Fast & Furiousness

about 8 years ago

Lin, Part 6: Fast Five. Mike and John discuss Justin Lin's sixth film, Fast Five.

Commentary: Trek Stars 178: Getting Rid of the Thes

about 8 years ago

Lin, Part 5: Fast & Furious. John and Mike are joined by Zach Moore to discuss Justin Lin's fifth movie, Fast & Furious.

View the full Commentary: Trek Stars episode directory >

Commentary: Trek Stars 2: The Roddenberry Box / November 15, 2012 by Trek fm

Roddenberry Part 1: Star Trek.

This week, Max and Mike begin a series which looks at the career of Gene Roddenberry as a television creator. Part 1 examines Roddenberry’s work in Star Trek. We discuss the impact that The Original Series had on the medium, the mystery of why The Animated Series didn’t work at all, what The Motion Picture tells us about how Phase II would’ve been, and how Roddenberry’s take on The Next Generation has influenced the franchise since his death. So grab a cup of tea, Earl Grey, hot, and settle in for half an hour of semi-entertaining musings.

Hosts

Mike Shindler and Max Hegel

Chapters

Creating Star Trek
The Animated Series
Phase II and The Motion Picture
The Next Generation
Final Thoughts

More Recent Episodes Of Commentary: Trek Stars

Commentary: Trek Stars

Commentary: Trek Stars 182: Let's See What's Out There

about 8 years ago

Series Finale. Mike and John reflect the past three and a half years of podcasting.

Commentary: Trek Stars 181: Deep Cuts

about 8 years ago

Lin, Part 8: Recap. Mike and John recap their series on Justin Lin.

Commentary: Trek Stars 180: Faster, More Intense

about 8 years ago

Lin, Part 7: Furious 6. John and Mike are joined by Megan from Educating Geeks to discuss Justin Lin's Furious 6.

Commentary: Trek Stars 179: The Avengers of Fast & Furiousness

about 8 years ago

Lin, Part 6: Fast Five. Mike and John discuss Justin Lin's sixth film, Fast Five.

Commentary: Trek Stars 178: Getting Rid of the Thes

about 8 years ago

Lin, Part 5: Fast & Furious. John and Mike are joined by Zach Moore to discuss Justin Lin's fifth movie, Fast & Furious.

View the full Commentary: Trek Stars episode directory >

Commentary: Trek Stars 1: A Play on a Play on Words / November 8, 2012 by Trek fm

The World Beyond Star Trek.

Welcome to the very first episode of Commentary: Trek Stars! Join Mike and Max of Commentary Track Stars (get it?) as they take a look at the work of Star Trek creators outside of Trek. In this episode, we tell you who we are and what you can expect from the show. Enjoy!